Type: True wireless earbuds Noise canceling: No Battery life: 6 hours (single charge) Weight: 4.28g earbuds, 37.91g case Apple’s third generation of its mid-range AirPods was released in the latter half of 2022. They’re not a radical reinvention of the wheel, but they are a significant improvement on the previous generation. The inclusion of Spatial Audio is very exciting, helping you feel more immersed than ever in your music, as though you’re physically surrounded by the instruments of the band or orchestra. Granted, there’s no active noise canceling – you need to step up to the AirPods Pro for that, which requires a considerably higher cash outlay. These AirPods are going to make the most sense for the majority of users – particularly those already invested in the Apple ecosystem. Type: True wireless earbuds Noise canceling: Yes Battery life: 8 hours, or 5 hours with ANC (single charge) Weight: 5g earbuds, 48g case Slick, compact and well-designed, these earbuds look the part without being overwrought, and they’ve got sound quality where it counts. The Active Noise Canceling (ANC) is superb. We tested it in a variety of situations, and found it consistently delivered. Furthermore, for those times you do need to hear what’s around you, the Studio Buds also use their exterior mics to offer Transparency mode. Well priced and frequently discounted, the Beats Studio Buds are an excellent choice. Battery life is middling, particularly with ANC active, but that’s our only real bugbear! We’ve picked out mid-range options for each brand, as these are going to be the best choice for the majority of users. In the Apple corner, we have the latest generation of standard AirPods – the AirPods 3, announced in September 2022. Slotting beneath the high-end AirPods Pro, these earbuds deliver an impressive audio quality upgrade compared to the previous generation, which debuted in 2019. But is it enough of an upgrade? It may not be, because in the Beats corner we have something a bit special – the Beats Studio Buds. First released and reviewed by us in 2021, these high-quality buds have a more understated design than many Beats ‘phones in the past, and deliver excellent sound quality with optional Active Noise Canceling. And while they may not integrate with other Apple devices quite as smoothly as AirPods will, they are a little cheaper, both in RRP and in actual street price. If you’re a fan of Beats, why not check out our Beats vs Bose (opens in new tab) piece as well. So, which should you choose? AirPods vs Beats? There’s only one way to find out – let’s dive in and compare the two.
AirPods vs Beats: Design
You may think that one pair of AirPods looks much like another, but the AirPods 3 have been refreshed in a few welcome ways. The housings have been redesigned for improved comfort, and the shorter stems now include touch capacitive force sensors – meaning they can be squeezed to control playback, accept calls, etc. The earbuds having IPX4 water-resistance is welcome, and should protect the buds from errant sweat while you’re working out, or from a sudden downpour. The Beats Studio Buds, meanwhile, stand out with an immediately striking ovoid form factor. They may seem odd at first glance, but once you slip them into your ear the shape makes sense – the bulbous body is comfortable but secure, and they simply stay where they are, even if you’re exercising. There are raised ridges on the sides that display the Beats logo, and also house physical control buttons, allowing you to play/pause, skip tracks and switch noise-canceling mode. While we dinged the Beats a little for not offering a volume control option in the physical buttons, this has been added in a subsequent firmware update. So no complaints here! Verdict: Tie
AirPods vs Beats: Performance and sound quality
If you’ve tried Beats before, the Studio Buds are a revelation. There’s none of that all-dominating bass heard out of previous Beats headphones. The bass in the Studio Buds is punchy, yes, but it sits sensibly in the mix and doesn’t overpower everything else. When we put them to the test across the rest of the audio range, we were consistently impressed. The dense opening medley of Steely Dan’s ‘Do It Again’, for instance, came out clear as a bell, with no individual elements getting lost in the shuffle. The overall sound profile is just beautifully balanced, and really impressive for a pair of buds at this price. The Beats’ Active Noise Canceling is also top-notch. Spookily good sometimes, the way noise canceling can be – it’s entirely possible that something loud might be happening right next to you and you won’t notice. In case you’re in a situation where that would be a problem, the Beats also offer a ‘Transparency’ mode, which uses the built-in exterior mics to feed outside sounds in. Useful if you’re listening out for an alarm, or otherwise need to have your wits about you. Audio performance of the AirPods’ third generation, meanwhile, has been kicked up a notch and is generally excellent. The included Spatial Audio technology lets you fully immerse yourself in your tracks, especially if they’ve been recorded in Dolby Atmos. It’s well-balanced and offers superb fidelity, whether you’re listening to music or watching films. Ultimately, we think the Beats offer a slightly better listening experience – especially given the fact that the Studio Buds have Active Noise Canceling. There’s not a lot in it though, and it may just come down to personal preference. Verdict: Beats
AirPods vs Beats: Battery life
This is a close fight, as both the AirPods 3 and the Beats Studio Buds offer a pretty similar proposition in the battery life department. Both sets of buds come with their own charging case – and the wireless case is now standard on the AirPods 3 (it was a pricey optional extra on the previous generation). Neither set of buds exactly excels in this department, but overall the AirPods do come out ahead. Apple promises about six hours of playtime, with four extra charges available in the case – so that’s a theoretical 30 hours of listening time before you need to intervene with a power supply. The Beats, meanwhile, can theoretically do up to eight hours of playtime on one charge, though this drops down to five if you’re using Active Noise Canceling – which a lot of the time you probably are. The charging case will only deliver two full charges, so that’s a theoretical maximum of 24 hours listening time. Still trailing the AirPods, even if you never touch the ANC. Winner: AirPods
AirPods vs Beats: Connectivity
We’re going to make an assumption here. Namely, that if you’re researching AirPods vs Beats, you’re already somewhat invested in the Apple ecosystem. (If you’re an Android user and somehow got this far, we can save you some time: stop reading and get the Beats. You’ll get much better value for money.) For Apple users, the question is a little less cut and dried. The AirPods offer quite a lot, connectivity-wise. Hooking them up to your iPhone or other Apple device is as delightfully smooth a process as you’d expect, requiring you to simply open the case and tap the screen once. You also get a healthy load of connected features, such as Announce Notifications (which reads you out important updates), Group Facetime with Spatial Audio, and Audio Sharing. Of course, the fact that Apple owns the Beats brand means that the Beats Studio Buds will do the majority of this as well. You can activate the Beats Studio Buds with ‘Hey Siri’, share your audio with a friend, get the Beats to announce your notifications and a whole lot more. iPhone users are spoiled for choice, frankly. Winner: Tie, assuming you’re an Apple user. Beats if not.
AirPods vs Beats: Value
Then there’s also the fact that the Beats Studio Buds pack in Active Noise Cancelation, which AirPods users have to fork out for the even pricier AirPods Pro in order to get. Winner: Beats
Should you buy AirPods or Beats?
This has been a close-run competition – ultimately you have no bad options here. The latest-generation AirPods offer a superlative listening experience thanks to Spatial Audio, and integrate swimmingly with all your iOS devices. The Beats Studio Buds, meanwhile, pair a striking ergonomic design with a beautifully balanced listening experience, and throw that uncanny Active Noise Canceling tech into the mix. If you’re going to make us choose – and we’re guessing you are – then ultimately we’re giving it to the Beats Studio buds. These excellent earbuds simply offer better value for money, especially when you factor in real-world prices. We love the audio mix we get with the Beats Studio Buds, and while the bold-colour design may not be for everyone, you can’t argue with how comfortable and secure they feel.
